klein,
Below are two entries that I would like to count as 1. I am planning to write another blog this week about one of the other stories we read. The first one (directly below) is not exactly what you asked for but I wrote it because it felt fun and I think it was important to help me see the story from a different perspective. The one after that it more what you asked for. It is looking into the “citizen’s” life a few years after the accident. I hope you enjoy reading the posts, I know I enjoyed writing them…I really liked this short story, it is so short and yet so meaningful.
Samuel
By: Grace Paley
What is a citizen? In the dictionary, it is “a native or naturalized member of a state or nation who owes allegiance to its government and is entitled to its protection.” However, to me a citizen means more than that. A citizen is someone who, without fail, will do the right thing. As I left work, it was a hot, but comfortable day in New York City. I thought it was just another normal afternoon; I would get to the subway station, wait for about fifteen minutes for the subway to arrive, get on, relax for the ride, then get off at stop fifteen and walk half a block to my apartment. I had no idea of how far from normal this day would be. As I boarded the subway, I was oblivious to the fact that there were four young boys playing on the platforms between the subway cars. I sat down next to a man wearing a suit and a large black coat. Across the aisle was a woman in a bright pink patterned dress sitting next to another man, also in a suit and a large black coat. The conductor of the subway called out for everyone to reach his or her seats, for the subway would soon lurch on to its next destination. The subway began to move; it was then that I noticed the four boys on the platform. My first reaction was to call out to them and tell them to come inside the car and sit down. Unfortunately, I was afraid that the other passengers would reprimand my actions and that my admonition to the boys would have no effect. Therefore, I stayed seated and continued to watch them intently until the man sitting beside me noticed the boys as well. He began to tell me of the days when he used to do brave things like the boys we were watching. I was too interested in the boys to pay much attention to what the man sitting next to me was saying or anything else that was happening in the subway car. That is, until I noticed the other man, sitting across the aisle. He began to twist and turn in his seat. All of a sudden, it occurred to me that this man, for whatever reason, was unhappy with the actions of the four boys. He seemed a decent man, and I must be honest when I say, I half hoped he would get up and confront the boys himself. About five minutes later, he did get up and I was still hopeful that he was headed to talk to the boys. As he walked down the aisle he had the appearance of a decent citizen. He walked in a tall, unconcerned and calm manner and appeared to be doing the right thing by going to talk to the boys. Within a split second, all of that changed. Before I knew it, he had yanked on the emergency cord, which brought the subway to a screeching halt. I watched with horror as the boys attempted to regain their balance. One boy, named Samuel, failed to regain his balance and fell between the subway cars and was trampled underneath the large, rotating, metal wheels. I was shocked at the man’s actions. He seemed so normal; nothing distinguished him from the man sitting next to me. It was just then that I realized the two men could not have been more different. The man sitting next to me lived a boyhood of daring stunts and actions of bravery while the other man, still standing by the emergency cord, had lived a sheltered boyhood with very little excitement, and very few bold gestures and dangerous opportunities. I will never forget the angry man on the subway who was jealous of four boys’ intrepid explorations of the platforms between the subway cars. To this day, I remember the man who was no citizen at all and who committed a selfish and hateful crime ending in the death of an innocent little boy, known as Samuel.
Samuel
By: Grace Paley
The man entered his office building carrying a briefcase and an umbrella. As he approached the elevators, the receptionist kindly greeted him, not knowing what he had done only three years before. The man entered the elevator and pressed the button for floor eight, where his law office was located. As he entered his office, his co-worker, Robert, offered him salutations and walked with him down the long corridor to his corner office. Robert was completely aware of the fact that only three years ago his boss in the corner office had selfishly killed a little boy named Samuel in a tragic subway accident. Robert, with three sons of his own, seemed unfazed by the story, which occasionally circulated around the office when the boss had a bad day. For instance, last Tuesday; the boss came into the office late because the subway had stalled on the tracks. He was in an exceedingly foul mood upon entering the office. When his secretary, Mary, offered him a blueberry muffin from the bakery down the street, he gruffly said, “no”, and marched to his corner office and shut the door. He did not come out until eight o’clock when he left for the day. During his time in the office, many people speculated about what he must have been doing. Some said work while others said he was reflecting on the “accident.” Robert, who had worked for his boss for five years, told of the accident. He also explained that whenever he and his boss ride the subway together he is very quiet, while he sits and reads the New York Times. However, none of them can really know what their boss does when his door is closed, all they know is that they are never to bother him when his door is shut, he made that clear to each employee when he or she began to work at his law firm. The one thing that was never mentioned at the office, probably because no one knew, was what the boss did when he returned home for the evening. Some nights he laughed about the accident, whether to help him forget it or because he thought that Samuel deserved what came to him is unknown. However, sometimes he sits on his green couch and stares into space wishing he could go back to the day the accident happened and change its outcome. Even he himself was not sure why he had pulled the emergency cord, resulting in the boy’s death. Was it out of anger? Or jealousy of the boys’ fun childhood? No one will ever know. All we know is that the little boy known as Samuel will never again walk the streets of New York City.